RANKING ·
Highest return on assets in Ohio
132 of 160 banks in Ohio that filed for the quarter ended June 30, 2026 are ranked. At least $100 million in total assets. Institutions with equal values share a rank. Source: FDIC quarterly financial data.
| Rank | Institution | Headquarters | Annualized return on assets for the quarter | Total assets |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nationwide Trust Company FSB | Columbus, OH | 15.49% | $154 million |
| 2 | Sutton Bank | Attica, OH | 5.08% | $1.7 billion |
| 3 | Spring Valley Bank | Wyoming, OH | 3.18% | $114 million |
| 4 | The Home Loan Savings Bank | Coshocton, OH | 2.61% | $387 million |
| 5 | The St. Henry Bank | St. Henry, OH | 2.56% | $436 million |
| 6 | The Citizens National Bank of Bluffton | Bluffton, OH | 2.52% | $1.1 billion |
| 7 | The National Bank of Adams County of West Union | West Union, OH | 2.15% | $115 million |
| 8 | Settlers Bank | Marietta, OH | 2.07% | $142 million |
| 9 | First Bank of Ohio | Tiffin, OH | 2.07% | $278 million |
| 10 | The Bank of Magnolia Company | Magnolia, OH | 2.04% | $108 million |
| 11 | Farmers & Merchants Bank | Miamisburg, OH | 1.98% | $359 million |
| 12 | First Federal Community Bank N.A. | Dover, OH | 1.97% | $995 million |
| 13 | Guardian Savings Bank | West Chester, OH | 1.94% | $1.4 billion |
| 14 | The Park National Bank | Newark, OH | 1.91% | $12.6 billion |
| 15 | Union Savings Bank | Cincinnati, OH | 1.80% | $4.0 billion |
| 16 | Greenville National Bank | Greenville, OH | 1.76% | $641 million |
| 17 | JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A. | Columbus, OH | 1.72% | $4.1 trillion |
| 18 | Signature Bank N.A. | Toledo, OH | 1.72% | $1.3 billion |
| 19 | Minster Bank | Minster, OH | 1.69% | $812 million |
| 20 | The Peoples Bank Co. | Coldwater, OH | 1.65% | $859 million |
| 21 | Main Street Bank Corp. | Wooster, OH | 1.65% | $1.6 billion |
| 22 | The Twin Valley Bank | West Alexandria, OH | 1.63% | $138 million |
| 23 | SSB Community Bank | Strasburg, OH | 1.63% | $297 million |
| 24 | First Financial Bank | Cincinnati, OH | 1.55% | $22.4 billion |
| 25 | The Old Fort Banking Company | Old Fort, OH | 1.52% | $844 million |
| 26 | The Commercial and Savings Bank of Millersburg, Ohio | Millersburg, OH | 1.50% | $1.3 billion |
| 27 | The Hamler State Bank | Hamler, OH | 1.48% | $125 million |
| 28 | The Corn City State Bank | Deshler, OH | 1.47% | $104 million |
| 29 | Unified Bank | Martins Ferry, OH | 1.46% | $872 million |
| 30 | The Farmers State Bank | New Madison, OH | 1.45% | $330 million |
| 31 | New Carlisle Federal Savings Bank | New Carlisle, OH | 1.45% | $330 million |
| 32 | The North Side Bank and Trust Company | Cincinnati, OH | 1.44% | $1.2 billion |
| 33 | Lcnb National Bank | Lebanon, OH | 1.44% | $2.2 billion |
| 34 | Civista Bank | Sandusky, OH | 1.43% | $4.3 billion |
| 35 | First National Bank in New Bremen | New Bremen, OH | 1.43% | $467 million |
| 36 | The Hocking Valley Bank | Athens, OH | 1.43% | $354 million |
| 37 | The Farmers & Merchants State Bank | Archbold, OH | 1.41% | $3.5 billion |
| 38 | Home Savings and Loan Company of Kenton, Ohio, the Dba Hslc | Kenton, OH | 1.40% | $245 million |
| 39 | The Richwood Banking Company Inc. | Richwood, OH | 1.39% | $1.3 billion |
| 40 | The Harrison Building and Loan Association | Harrison, OH | 1.39% | $268 million |
| 41 | National Cooperative Bank N.A. | Hillsboro, OH | 1.37% | $4.3 billion |
| 42 | The Farmers and Merchants Bank | Caldwell, OH | 1.37% | $136 million |
| 43 | The Fort Jennings State Bank | Fort Jennings, OH | 1.37% | $286 million |
| 44 | Waterford Bank N.A. | Toledo, OH | 1.34% | $1.8 billion |
| 45 | The Citizens Bank Company | Beverly, OH | 1.34% | $335 million |
| 46 | The Croghan Colonial Bank | Fremont, OH | 1.34% | $1.4 billion |
| 47 | Osgood Bank | Osgood, OH | 1.33% | $486 million |
| 48 | Vinton County National Bank | Mcarthur, OH | 1.33% | $1.6 billion |
| 49 | The First National Bank of Mcconnelsville | Mcconnelsville, OH | 1.31% | $200 million |
| 50 | Community Savings | Caldwell, OH | 1.30% | $285 million |
| 51 | U.S. Bank N.A. | Cincinnati, OH | 1.29% | $706 billion |
| 52 | Keybank N.A. | Cleveland, OH | 1.29% | $189 billion |
| 53 | Peoples Bank | Marietta, OH | 1.29% | $9.5 billion |
| 54 | The Farmers National Bank of Canfield | Canfield, OH | 1.28% | $7.2 billion |
| 55 | Cfbank N.A. | Columbus, OH | 1.28% | $2.2 billion |
| 56 | Merchants National Bank | Hillsboro, OH | 1.27% | $1.3 billion |
| 57 | The Apple Creek Banking Company | Apple Creek, OH | 1.27% | $271 million |
| 58 | The First National Bank of Sycamore | Sycamore, OH | 1.27% | $239 million |
| 59 | The Killbuck Savings Bank Company | Killbuck, OH | 1.26% | $954 million |
| 60 | Fifth Third Bank N.A. | Cincinnati, OH | 1.24% | $299 billion |
| 61 | The Fahey Banking Company | Marion, OH | 1.23% | $385 million |
| 62 | The Community Bank | Zanesville, OH | 1.20% | $680 million |
| 63 | First Federal Community Bank of Bucyrus | Bucyrus, OH | 1.18% | $374 million |
| 64 | The Citizens National Bank of Woodsfield | Woodsfield, OH | 1.18% | $154 million |
| 65 | Farmers State Bank | West Salem, OH | 1.15% | $188 million |
| 66 | The State Bank and Trust Company | Defiance, OH | 1.15% | $1.6 billion |
| 67 | Woodsfield Savings Bank | Woodsfield, OH | 1.15% | $123 million |
| 68 | The Huntington National Bank | Columbus, OH | 1.13% | $283 billion |
| 69 | Riverhills Bank | Milford, OH | 1.11% | $341 million |
| 70 | North Valley Bank | Zanesville, OH | 1.09% | $427 million |
| 71 | First State Bank | Winchester, OH | 1.07% | $1.2 billion |
| 72 | 1st National Bank | Lebanon, OH | 1.05% | $247 million |
| 73 | First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Delta | Delta, OH | 1.05% | $246 million |
| 74 | Miami Savings Bank | Miamitown, OH | 1.04% | $148 million |
| 75 | Peoples State Bank | New Lexington, OH | 1.02% | $286 million |
| 76 | Portage Community Bank | Ravenna, OH | 1.01% | $552 million |
| 77 | The Citizens National Bank of Mcconnelsville | Mcconnelsville, OH | 1.01% | $102 million |
| 78 | Ohio State Bank | Bexley, OH | 1.00% | $484 million |
| 79 | The Baltic State Bank | Baltic, OH | 0.96% | $130 million |
| 80 | Consumers National Bank | Minerva, OH | 0.96% | $1.3 billion |
| 81 | The First National Bank of Pandora | Pandora, OH | 0.96% | $299 million |
| 82 | The Farmers Bank and Savings Company | Pomeroy, OH | 0.94% | $472 million |
| 83 | The Genoa Banking Company | Genoa, OH | 0.94% | $748 million |
| 84 | The Andover Bank | Andover, OH | 0.93% | $595 million |
| 85 | The Cincinnatus Savings and Loan Company | Cincinnati, OH | 0.93% | $193 million |
| 86 | The First National Bank of Waverly | Waverly, OH | 0.91% | $196 million |
| 87 | The Sherwood State Bank | Sherwood, OH | 0.86% | $108 million |
| 88 | The First National Bank of Bellevue | Bellevue, OH | 0.85% | $310 million |
| 89 | Somerville Bank | Eaton, OH | 0.84% | $291 million |
| 90 | Liberty Savings Bank, F.S.B. | Wilmington, OH | 0.84% | $1.1 billion |
| 91 | The Peoples Savings and Loan Company | West Liberty, OH | 0.83% | $110 million |
| 92 | The Savings Bank | Circleville, OH | 0.82% | $520 million |
| 93 | Kingston National Bank | Kingston, OH | 0.82% | $586 million |
| 94 | Mechanics Bank | Mansfield, OH | 0.80% | $896 million |
| 95 | Buckeye Community Bank | Elyria, OH | 0.79% | $238 million |
| 96 | Mercer Savings Bank | Celina, OH | 0.79% | $176 million |
| 97 | The Ohio Valley Bank Company | Gallipolis, OH | 0.75% | $1.6 billion |
| 98 | Independence Bank | Independence, OH | 0.73% | $191 million |
| 99 | The Peoples Savings Bank | Urbana, OH | 0.72% | $189 million |
| 100 | Southern Hills Community Bank | Leesburg, OH | 0.70% | $210 million |
Rankings sort one published measure; they are not an overall judgment of any institution. Methodology · All rankings